Best roofing contractors in Carmichael
These are Carmichael's highest-scoring roofing contractors according to our methodology, which weighs ratings, review volume, recency and sentiment together. Every business below handles core roofing work, from tear-offs and tile to storm repairs, so the order reflects how consistently each one delivers rather than a difference in services offered.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to roofing contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Noah's Roofing | 89 | 4.9 (128) | — | Full roof replacements, insurance jobs |
| 2 | J. Ratch Construction | 84 | 4.9 (67) | — | Storm damage and tile roofs |
| 3 | America's Roofing Company | 82 | 5 (20) | — | Owner-managed small jobs |
| 4 | Carmichael Roofing Solutions | 79 | 4.8 (19) | — | New installs and gutter work |
| 5 | The Tom Yancey Company | 72 | 4.5 (53) | — | Long-term durability track record |
| 6 | Russ Johnson Construction, Inc. | 60 | 4.6 (11) | — | General exterior repairs |
| 7 | Freeman & Young Roofing | 43 | 5 (1) | — | New or lesser-known option |
| 8 | Carmichael Roofers | 32 | — | — | Broad service menu, unproven locally |
| 9 | Curtis Pacific Roofing | 22 | — | — | Unverified, no review history |
1. Noah's Roofing
4.9 (128 reviews)score 89/100
Noah's Roofing posts the highest composite score in Carmichael on a strong review base of 127, with a 4.9 rating and sentiment that's overwhelmingly positive. Crews led by named staff like Kevin and Bonnie are called out repeatedly for showing up on schedule and finishing ahead of the estimate, which is rare in this trade.
- Crew arrives on schedule and often finishes faster than quoted
- Clear, itemized pricing with no hidden fees or upsell pressure
- Named supervisors known for detailed, patient explanations
- Thorough cleanup, including magnetic sweeps of the yard
Watch out: A few reviewers mention a slow wait for the initial estimate, and one found the final price steep.
Google-verified128 Google reviewsmore than 40 years; founded in 1981
Services: roof repair, commercial roofing, roof replacement installation, roofing contractor
2. J. Ratch Construction
4.9 (67 reviews)score 84/100
J. Ratch Construction combines a 4.9 rating across 65 reviews with a reputation for same-day or next-day response when a roof is actively leaking. Reviewers single out Jeff's photo-documented findings and bids that regularly land well below competitors, especially on concrete tile and shake work.
- Bids often $5,000+ below competing quotes
- Fast emergency turnaround on leaks and storm damage
- Photo documentation makes findings easy to verify
- Extra repairs discovered mid-job are often fixed at no upcharge
Watch out: One sharply negative review describes rudeness from the owner when a mistake was raised, a contrast to the otherwise praise-heavy record.
Google-verified67 Google reviews
Services: commercial roofing, gutter services, roof repair, roofing contractor
3. America's Roofing Company
5 (20 reviews)score 82/100
America's Roofing Company has a perfect 5.0 rating across all 20 reviews, with owner Joe personally involved in projects from quote through completion. It's a smaller confidence sample than the top two, but the sentiment is unanimously positive with no documented complaints.
- Owner Joe is hands-on and quick to respond to calls
- Fast turnaround from quote to finished job
- In-house crew known for tidy, professional work
- Comfortable with complex extras like solar panel removal and reinstall
Watch out: Review volume is lower than the top-ranked options, so the track record is thinner.
Google-verified20 Google reviewsmore than 40 years
Services: commercial roofing, roof repair, roof replacement installation, roofing contractor
4. Carmichael Roofing Solutions
4.8 (19 reviews)score 79/100
Carmichael Roofing Solutions earns a 4.9 rating over 30 reviews, with reviewers consistently describing on-time, on-budget jobs handled by a polite, competent crew. It covers storm damage repair and new installations equally well according to the feedback.
- Jobs finish on schedule and stay within budget
- Crew described as professional and courteous throughout
- Handles both storm damage repair and new roof installs
- Attention to detail noted across multiple jobs
Watch out: One caller raised concerns about inconsistent phone routing and whether the operation matches its listed address, worth confirming directly before booking.
19 Google reviews
Services: roof inspection, roof repair, roof replacement installation, commercial roofing
5. The Tom Yancey Company
4.5 (53 reviews)score 72/100
The Tom Yancey Company has been around long enough that reviewers cite roofs still holding up after 20-plus years, with staff like Adrian and Scott praised for responsiveness and same-day inspections. That said, the sentiment here is mixed rather than uniformly positive.
- Same-day inspections available
- Documented 20+ year durability on completed roofs
- Responsive sales contact (Adrian named repeatedly)
- Crews clean up daily on site
Watch out: Several serious complaints describe subcontractor use despite the company's own no-subcontracting claim, plus one negligence dispute over water damage.
Google-verified53 Google reviewssince 1888
Services: commercial roofing, roof repair, roof replacement installation, roofing contractor
6. Russ Johnson Construction, Inc.
4.6 (11 reviews)score 60/100
Russ Johnson Construction gets solid marks for responsiveness and fair pricing on repair and remodel work, though the review count is small enough that the confidence here is low. Recency also lags behind the top picks, so it's worth checking they're still actively taking roofing jobs.
- Easy to reach and responsive to questions
- Fair pricing noted by reviewers
- Transparent about unexpected costs mid-job
- Experience with dry rot and general exterior repairs
Watch out: One reviewer felt the estimate visit was rushed, and the review base is small.
Google-verified11 Google reviews
Services: commercial roofing, residential roofing, roof repair, roof replacement installation
7. Freeman & Young Roofing
5 (1 reviews)score 43/100
Freeman & Young Roofing has just one review on record, a five-star rating, which isn't enough to draw real conclusions about consistency. Worth a call if you're gathering quotes, but treat it as an unknown quantity for now.
- Single review on file is a full five stars
Watch out: Too few reviews to gauge reliability; recency data is also unavailable.
1 Google reviews
Services: residential roofing, roof repair, roofing contractor
8. Carmichael Roofers
score 32/100
Carmichael Roofers advertises a wide residential and commercial service list with 7-day availability, but there are no reviews yet to back up a customer-experience read. It's listed here for completeness of the local market rather than a demonstrated track record.
- Advertises both residential and commercial roofing
- 7-day availability claimed on their site
Watch out: Zero reviews recorded, so there's no independent customer feedback to check against.
Services: residential roofing, commercial roofing, roof repair, gutter services
9. Curtis Pacific Roofing
score 22/100
Curtis Pacific Roofing has no review volume and the lowest composite score in this set, so there's little to go on beyond a name in the directory. Get quotes elsewhere first and treat this one as a last resort until more feedback exists.
- Listed as an active roofing contractor in the Carmichael area
Watch out: No reviews or verification data available, so quality and reliability are unknown.
Services: commercial roofing, residential roofing, roof repair, roofing contractor